Pros and Cons of Different Types of Mortgage
Previous lessons described different types of mortgage loans, each with
its own set of advantages and disadvantages. This
lesson summarizes the pros and cons.
How to Find the Best Mortgage: General Recommendations
The mortgage that is right for you will depend on your tolerance for
risk, your personal financial situation, and economic conditions.
Finding the right mortgage can be a challenge since you have
many options. However, knowing the pros and cons of
different types of mortgages will help narrow your search.
- Choose the mortgage with the lowest total cost during the
time that you own your home. (You can see examples that
illustrate how to find total mortgage cost in the
total cost case study
and in the
choose between two mortgages case study.)
- If you will only own the home for a few years, consider an
adjustable-rate mortgage.
They typically have lower initial rates.
- If you will own the home for many years and interest
rates are at historic highs, consider
an adjustable-rate mortgage. It will have a lower starting
rate than a
fixed-rate mortgage;
and the rate may
decline over time, when you can refinance into a fixed-rate mortgage.
(Note that the rate may not decline
immediately. In fact, it may go up. Follow this
recommendation only if you have the financial wherewithal
to survive a rise in interest rate.)
- If you will own the home for many years and interest
rates are at historic lows, consider
a fixed-rate mortgage. It will lock in the low rate
over the life of your loan.
- Some mortgages (e.g.,
interest-only loans,
graduated-payment loans)
are attractive for their low monthly payments. Consider
these options only if you expect to have a problem paying the
monthly note.
If you plan to live in the home for more than a few years, these
loans may be poor choices. Here's why.
- The interest-only loans do not build equity through
amortization, and the graduated payment loans can
result in negative amortization.
- Compared to other types of loans, the total
mortgage cost over the life of the loan tends to be
higher.
- If you are risk-averse and it is
unclear whether a fixed-rate or an adjustable-rate mortgage is
better, you may be happier with the fixed-rate mortgage.
For cautious borrowers, the fixed-rate loan offers the peace of mind
that comes from knowing that your mortgage payment will not increase
over the life of the loan.
Advantages and disadvantages of specific types of mortgages are summarized
in the tables below.
Pros and Cons of Fixed-Rate Mortgages
This tutorial has described four different kinds of fixed-rate mortgages.
Here are the advantages and disadvantages of each.
Conventional fixed-rate loan |
- Do not suffer when market rates rise
- Predictable P&I payment
|
- Do not benefit when market rates fall
- Initial interest rate is higher than ARM
|
Fixed-rate balloon |
- Do not suffer when market rates rise
- Predictable P&I payment
- Lower interest than conventional fixed rate
|
- Do not benefit when market rates fall
- Initial rate may be higher than ARM
- May need to refinance to pay off balloon
- Rates at payoff could be unattractive
|
Interest-only loan |
- Do not suffer when market rates rise
- Predictable P&I payment
- Lower monthly payments
|
- Do not benefit when market rates fall
- Initial rate may be higher than ARM
- Must refinance, renew, or repay early
- No debt reduction through amortization
|
Biweekly loan |
- Do not suffer when market rates rise
- Predictable P&I payment
- Smaller payments
- If you "squeeze" in the equivalent of a 13th
monthly payment, you pay off loan quicker
|
- Do not benefit when market rates fall
- Initial rate may be higher than ARM
- More payments per year
|
Pros and Cons of Adjustable-Rate Mortgages
This tutorial has described six different kinds of adjustable-rate mortgages.
Advantages and disadvantages of each are summarized below.
Standard ARM |
- Payments decline when market rates fall
- Low initial rate, compared to fixed rate
|
- Payments increase when rates rise
- No stability; payments change over time
|
Convertible ARM |
- Payments decline when rates fall
- Low initial rate, compared to fixed rate
- Can "lock in" low rates if rates fall
|
- Payments increase when rates rise
- Higher initial rate than standard ARM
- No stability; payments vary with market
- Must pay fee to "lock in"
|
Two-step mortgage |
- Initial rate is fixed for a period of time
- Payments decline when market rate falls
- Low initial rate, compared to fixed rate
|
- Payments fluctuate one time with market
- Payments increase when rate rises
- Some risk, since future rate is unknown
|
Balloon ARM |
- Payments decline when market rates fall
- Low initial rate, compared to fixed rate
|
- Payments increase when rates rise
- No stability; payments vary with market
- May need to refinance to pay off balloon
- Rates at payoff could be unattractive
|
Interest-only ARM |
- Payments decline when market rates fall
- Low monthly payments
|
- Payments increase when rates rise
- No stability; payments vary with market
- Does not reduce the loan principal
|
Graduated-payment loan |
- Low initial monthly payments
|
|